Research and action for fair and accountable policing

About Twitter Instagram Facebook Donate

Choice without information is dangerous

Kam Gill discusses the need for greater availability of data on policing in the lead up to the Police and Crime Commissioners elections in November.

​In the lead up to the election of the first police and crime commissioners, the availability and awareness of data on policing is a pressing issue. The information required for an interested citizen to make a relatively informed choice in a general election is published daily. It is broadcast regularly on almost all radio channels – some channels are almost entirely devoted to broadcasting and discussing it – and features nightly at least 5 of the main television channels. While there is, rightly no requirement for a citizen to read a newspaper to vote, should they decide to become more informed about politics they do not have to look very hard. However, this is not the case when it comes to information about policing.

The elections represent the most significant change to our policing system in 150 years and will (hopefully) provide people with more say over how policing takes place locally.  To make an informed decision over who should be a Police and Crime Commissioner, people will need information on how policing operates in their area – crime rates, arrest rates, budget implications of use of various powers, annual budget for broader crime prevention (youth clubs, drug & alcohol treatment, domestic violence refuges) ethnic breakdown of the local force and usage of exceptional powers such as Section 60 to name just a few. Statistics on Race and the criminal justice system are released once a year. The disproportionality figures mainly in relation to stop and search then raise a flurry of debate in the press and the topic largely disappears until resurrected by a race scandal – admittedly a sadly regular occurrence over the past 12 months. On a local level the curious electorate will have to navigate the patchy provision of data on local police service websites. The accessibility and transparency of police websites vary greatly across the country.  There is the option of a Freedom of Information request to an individual force if one wants information not readily available. However, this is a time-consuming, technical process with no guarantee of success. It is not a viable option for the casual voter who just wants a few more hard stats on which to basis their decision.

Without a significant effort to inform the public about the policing data available, and to facilitate access to that information; the habits of inquiry required for an informed electorate will not be embedded by the time elections roll round in November. StopWatch will be endeavouring to provide as much information as possible. We will have factsheets on stop and search, and we will try to provide basic policing stats for different regions (Watch this space). However we can only do so much, the emphasis must lie on the bodies that generate and collect this data.  People will be making decisions that will have potentially profound impacts on how they, their friends, family and the rest of the community experience policing. It is vital they do so with all the facts at their fingertips.

Kam Gill

StopWatch member

About the author

Kam Gil. a researcher on the StopWatch team.

More articles


StopWatch and the Open Society Justice Initiative submission to the UN Human Rights Council

StopWatch and the Open Society Justice Initiative recently submitted a contribution to the United Nations Human Rights Council review of the United Kingdom.


StopWatch launched by Rev Jesse Jackson

StopWatch was launched Monday 18 October, 2010 at King's College London where key speaker Reverend Jesse Jackson called for an end to "racial profiling" on both sides of the Atlantic.


Liberty responds to proposed PACE guidance amendment

Liberty has warned the government against draft police guidance that would allow race to be a basis for stop and search without suspicion under section 60 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994.


StopWatch responds to the PACE code of practice

​StopWatch submitted a response to the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE) Code of Practice A.


StopWatch responds to 'Policing in the 21st century'

​StopWatch submitted a response to the government consultation document Policing in the 21st Century: Reconnecting the Police and the People.


Support our work

We take one-off donations and regular payments. Any amount we receive helps to support us in our mission and keeps us independent


Sign up to our newsletter

For regular updates on our activities and to learn how you can get involved with us

Sign up to our newsletter